Men's Football
- Plays of the Year 2023The top 30 plays in Muhlenberg College athletics for 2023.
- Six Named All-Region in FootballSix Muhlenberg players were named to the D3football.com All-Region 2 team.
- Nye Named to All-America Second TeamMuhlenberg senior tight end James Nye was named to the American Football Coaches Association Division III All-America second team.
- Seven Named to Sportsmanship TeamSeven Muhlenberg athletes were recognized for their behavior with their selection to the 2023 Fall All-Centennial Conference Sportsmanship Team.
- 82 Named to Academic Honor RollEighty-two Muhlenberg College student-athletes were named to the Centennial Conference Academic Honor Roll for the fall 2023 season.